Choosing the sails and sail handling setup on Puffin was a fun part of the process, but also a bit nerve-wracking as there are so many factors to consider and trade-offs to make. It’s difficult and expensive to fix mistakes after the boat is built, so every detail has to be thought through. It took a lot of discussions and research and I really want to thank Benjamin and Matthieu at Outremer for their detailed advice and patience with all my questions!
I feel like sails and sail handling systems are possibly the most critical areas of the selection process when purchasing a new catamaran. I’ve had poor setups in the past and they make it a frustrating experience to handle and trim the sails and can be downright dangerous in certain conditions. A good setup gives you the confidence to handle any conditions you encounter, and can make your boat a pleasure to sail, so it’s well worth the effort to get it right.
The basic setup on the 4X is good, but after previous lessons learned and my goal of configuring Puffin for easy single-handed sailing, I needed to go over every detail to make sure we would end up with a solution that meets all our needs. In this post I will go over what we are trying to accomplish with our sail plan and the solution we have chosen for Puffin. I’m going to cover the important things I wished I had known when I bought my other boats, and what I have learned from my earlier mistakes. This post gets a bit technical, so for those that want to skip the science lesson, here are the top three things I wished I knew when I was buying my first boat:
- It’s a sailboat. Sails matter, a lot! Don’t skimp. Good sails and sail balance can make you love sailing your boat. Poor sail balance can make you hate it, and can put your boat and lives at risk
- Most manufacturers put cheap sails and grossly inadequate sail handling systems on their boats. They do this to keep the price low, and because virtually nobody attending a boat show wants to talk about sailplan design. Beware of this, you’re buying a sailboat not a motor boat, see point 1!
- Work with a manufacturer you trust, and talk to them about your sails and sail handling. Good manufacturers like Outremer are happy to do this. When they give you advice, listen to them! They have seen just about every scenario you can imagine and they know what works and what doesn’t out on the water.
Our design goals
Let’s get started with Puffin’s sailplan. In order to determine the best solution, I had to first define our goals. Here’s what is important to me on our boat:
- Excellent light wind performance – I talked about our goals for light wind sailing in the Chasing Performance post. A lightweight, well designed boat is fundamental to this, but we also need sails that can provide maximum power with minimum weight.
- Easy reefing – We want the minimum amount of sail up at any time to maintain our desired boat speed. This means that we will spend a lot of time sailing with one or more reefs in the mainsail. We need to be able to easily take and remove reefs, and we need to make sure there is minimal wear and chafe when sailing long distances with a reefed sail.
- Balanced rig – As we reef the mainsail we also need to reduce the headsail area to keep the boat balanced and minimize the load on the autopilot. The headsail area has to be easily adjustable and the location of the center of effort must move back towards the mast as the headsail area is reduced.
- Controls at the helm – We want to minimize the need for going forward to make changes to the sails, so most of the operations need to be done from the helm station.
- Single-handed operation – All sailing maneuvers on the boat need to be as easy as possible when performed by a single person
- Storm mode – We need to have a storm configuration that’s simple and safe to configure and can handle winds in the 40-50 knot range
There’s no one or perfect answer in any of this, so every decision becomes a compromise. I had to determine my priorities for choosing among different alternatives. I decided that I would start with high performance sails, but after that I would put ease of single-handing above performance when making tradeoffs.
We chose North 3Di Endurance for our 68 square meter mainsail. The sail is fully battened with three reef points. We added three colored lateral bands to assist with trimming. Although the sail in the image has numbers on it, we deleted the sail numbers from our sail. They’re ugly and unnecessary for cruising.
North mainsails are almost half the weight of the equivalent hydranet sail and they are able to keep a good airfoil shape in light winds. The downside is they are not as tough as hydranet and they will chafe if not handled carefully.
For our 55 square meter Genoa we chose North 3Di Endurance.
We get the same benefits with the 3Di Genoa as the main. Significantly lighter and holds an excellent airfoil in light winds, so more power. There are two donwsides to 3Di genoas. They have less resistance to chafe, and they don’t roller reef very cleanly. Our Genoa is on a roller furler and because of the molded airfoil shape of the 3Di sail they work best when fully unfurled. When furling partially to reef, they develop creases along the luff and lose performance. This sail uses a new system by North to reduce the creasing along the luff when reefing. I’ve not seen or used this, so will have to report back later on whether it works or not.
We are adding a staysail to Puffin, which is not standard on the 4X, but is offered by Outremer as an option. In my experience, catamarans over 40-45 feet should have a staysail (I explain why below). We added this on Wildling, and it completely changed our sailing experience. We were able to point higher and drive the boat easily upwind in strong conditions, and we maintained helm balance as the sails were reefed.
Our staysail on Puffin is on a movable inner stay which is tensioned in place when needed. I expect to be using the staysail a lot when sailing upwind, so we are rigging it to use the self tacking track. This is the same track the Outremer 45 uses for its self tacking jib, which we don’t have on our 4X. Because it’s on a movable stay, we are not using a roller furler, instead the sail will be hanked on, with a single slab reefing point.
We had to make a tradeoff here. The optimum staysail size recommended by North is 32 square meters, but that would require the sail to be rigged slightly overlapping the mast and not self-tacking, making it more work to route the sheets when deploying and more work to tack. From past experience I know we will spend a lot of our time upwind under staysail, so because my tradeoff criteria favors easy single-handed sailing over performance, I went with the smaller, self-tacking staysail.
The storm jib takes care of winds in the 40-50+ knot range. It hopefully won’t see much use. I needed ours on Wildling when we sailed 12 hours in 45-50 knots and was damn glad to have it, so there’s no question for me about getting one on Puffin.
The Balance Problem
One of the lessons I learned the hard way is the importance of rig balance when sailing upwind in developed conditions. This is so important, and so seldom mentioned by boat manufacturers, that I’m going to go into the science behind it a bit to explain what it is, and why I care. Let’s start by looking at a boat with full main and jib in balance to understand the forces involved.
Imagine that our boat is sailing upwind with the wind at around 45 degrees to the bow. There are three important locations where a force is being exerted on the boat:
CE-main: This is the center of effort of the force pushing the mainsail sideways
CE-jib: The center of effort of the force pushing the jib sideways
CLR: The center of lateral resistance. This is like the post of a weather vane and opposes the sideways movement of the boat.
You can imagine if the boat is in balance and the force acting at CE-main is increased, the stern of the boat will tend to get pushed away from the wind. Also, if the force at CE-jib is increased the bow will get pushed downwind. If they are equal the boat will not rotate and will be balanced. You will feel this on the helm. The boat will sail on course with no helm pressure. When the forces are out of balance, the only way to stay on course is to compensate with the rudder. A small amount of rudder is fine, a large amount will overcome the auto-pilot, and if the force imbalance gets too large, the rudder can no longer compensate and the boat can no longer be held on its current course.
The relationship of forces can be represented by a simple lever diagram. In our high school physics class we learned the mass (or force at the CE for us) x distance on one side of the center of resistance is equal to the mass times the distance on the other side when the system is in balance.
Moving M2 further away requires a reduction in the force to maintain balance.
Just for fun, let’s do the math on our theoretical 4X diagram above. I’ll just pick a number for the force acting at CE-main because it doesn’t matter what the actual force is, what we want to understand is the balance relationship between the main and jib as a percentage of the mainsail force. So I’ll just use 100 for the force at CE-main and then solve for the force at CE-jib. This gives the following:
forceCEjib = (forceCEmain x D1) / D2
forceCEjib = (100 x 2383) / 3365
forceCEjib = 71
Balance ratio = 1 This rig is perfectly balanced
Everything is good here. Both sails are balanced around the CLR. The boat will maintain course, driving well with no helm pressure. (In reality the forceCEjib would be a bit less than this, and there would be a small amount of pressure imbalance turning the bow towards the wind (weather helm). This would be overcome with a degree or two of rudder, but that’s not important for this discussion).
Now, let’s see what happens when the wind builds and we reef the sails. We’re going to take two reefs in the main which will reduce it from 68 m2 to 41 m2 (about 40%) and we’re going to furl up our jib 40% as well. This is shown in the next diagram.
This configuration shifts both the CE locations forward, but it’s not until we do the math that we realize the magnitude of what’s really happened.
We can find the new balance ratio as a percentage of mainsail power by comparing the magnitude of each side of our balance equation. We will reduce both the main and jib force acting at the CE by 40% (by taking two reefs) and use the new distances measured on the drawing. Here’s what we get.
forceCEmain X 60% x 1768 = 60 x 1768 = 106,080
forceCEjib x 60% x 4960 = 42.6 x 4960 = 211,296
Balance ratio = 1.99 The jib is exerting double the mainsail force sideways
This dramatically changes our ratio of forces, and now the jib is generating twice the force of the main. The bow of this boat is being pushed hard to leeward and the rudders may not have enough surface area to compensate. The only solution is to keep furling the jib until the rudders can exert enough pressure to maintain course. Unfortunately we have to furl a lot because as we furl, the CE-jib keeps moving forward. With the further reduced jib we lose a lot of our power, the boat starts to slow and can no longer drive as well through the waves created in these conditions, this slows the boat down ever further. The dagger-boards lose lift as the speed reduces and the boat gets pushed to leeward making it even harder to maintain course. This leaves the helmsman with two choices. Change course or start the engines. On most catamarans at this point, the sails get stowed and the engines take over.
So What’s the Solution?
This problem is very solvable, but it requires a different upwind headsail setup. What we need to be able to do, is move the headsail CE backwards towards the CLR of the boat as we reef the sails. Our staysail will do this for us because it’s rigged on an inner stay, much closer to the mast than the roller furling jib or Genoa. The following diagrams show our sailplan configuration on Puffin, incorporating a staysail at different reefing points.
This is why a staysail is such an important safety feature on a catamaran and why we are adding it on Puffin. I mentioned in the performance post that we anticipate sailing a considerable amount of time with reefed sails, so having a staysail is even more important because we will so often be in a sail configuration where the staysail is the ideal headsail for the conditions.
Sail Handling Systems
Now we know what our sail configuration is going to be, the next step is to look at how we will raise, lower, reef and trim the sails to suit the different conditions.
The standard 4X sail handling design is very good, but there were a few changes that I wanted to make to make it a bit easier for single-handed sailing.
Fixed Carbon Mast
The biggest change to the base 4X design was my choice of a fixed, carbon fiber mast instead of the standard rotating mast. We give up some performance, but we gain the following benefits:
- Rope clutch for main halyard moves from the side of the mast to the salon roof in front of the helm station. A rotating mast needs to be free to rotate, so the halyard has to be blocked on the side of the mast. This means going forward every time the sail is raised or lowered and adds steps to reefing operations. The fixed mast lets us move the halyard blocker to the helm station.
- Rope clutches for reefing lines move from end of boom to the salon roof in front of the helm station. Same as above, the rotating mast requires crew to go to the mast end of the boom to release and secure the reefing line blockers. This is not needed with the fixed mast as these relocate to the helm.
- Removed mast angle control lines and blockers – The rigging for controlling the mast angle is not needed. This saves weight and cleans up the salon roof and helm station a bit.
- Simplified instruments – The mast angle sensor is not needed, which eliminates a potential point of failure and maintenance. Also, we can locate the radar dome on the mast spreader and not have to worry about the unreliable software compensation for mast angle when displaying radar plots.
- Redundant navigation lights – A fixed mast allows us to add a tri-color nav light at the mast head, in addition to the standard set of deck level lights. This is an extra level of safety and protects us if (when) we have a nav light go out.
Mainsail Reef Hook
This hopefully solves a problem I have struggled with on both my previous boats. When reefed, the line that secures the mainsail clew to the boom is under constant tension. It is the source of loud creaking noises, and the contact with the low friction ring at the clew causes a lot of chafe. We sail with reefs in a lot, so I really wanted to solve this issue. I discussed it with Matthieu, and it turns out Outremer are now offering an option on their boats that addresses this problem.
The Facnor Reef Lock captures the clew reef shackle and takes the load off the reefing line. No more chafe, and no more creaking! We are adding this to Puffin on our 1st reef point, which is the one we use the most and also places the most load on the reefing lines.
Remote Control Furling
The final sail handling modification was the addition of electric winches and remote control buttons so that the headsail can be furled on all points of sail single-handed. We converted the port cockpit winch to electric for ease of headsail furling. We made one of the port helm position winches electric to make it easy to raise the mainsail and spinnaker halyards and to lift someone up the mast. And we made the winch on the starboard side salon roof electric to make it easy for Robin to trim the Genoa if (when) I get injured.
The port cockpit winch handles the furling line for the Genoa. I want to be able to furl single-handed on starboard tack so I added an extra high speed winch button behind my feet at the helm station. To furl I put the furling line on the cockpit winch, go to the helm station and put the Genoa sheet on the winch, then ease the sheet as I push the furling winch button with my foot.
We added another remote control button for the port cockpit winch at the starboard side Genoa sheet winch position. This allows me to furl the Genoa single-handed when on port tack. To furl I put the furling line on the cockpit winch, go to the winch at the starboard side of the salon roof and put the Genoa sheet on the winch, then ease the sheet as I push the cockpit winch button with my foot.
What about downwind?
Downwind sails were pretty easy. I used the heck out of our Code-D Gennaker on Wildling, so I’m going to get another one for Puffin. It’s just so easy to hoist, stow and furl compared to a spinnaker, and what it lacks in performance it more than makes up for in ease of use and low stress sailing. The only modification I made to standard is that I am using a Karver KF8 furler for the Code-D. These things are bullet proof and very low friction, so they make it easy for either Robin or I to furl our Gennaker in windy conditions.
I’m also adding a (highly controversial) symmetric spinnaker. Most performance cruisers hate these things, but I like them. Ours is small with a heavyweight fabric (for a spi) and I use it when we’ve got moderate wind but large waves. In these conditions, it can be very uncomfortable sailing on a reach and I find I can keep everyone on board healthier and happier by dropping the main, setting the symmetric and going dead downwind. We’ll never set any speed records with this sail, but in some cases the relief it provides in nasty conditions is worth its weight in gold.
Hi Doug, great post and validates a lot of my thinking. We are building a much smaller Richard Woods design and my thinking regarding the rig set up is similar, particularly having everything manageable from the cockpit. Thanks fo the clear explanation on balance, I am having an inner forestay to run a storm sail on and now thinking about also adding a larger staysail in addition to the storm jib. Only major departure for me I’m choosing a reefable hanked on headsail rather than having on a furler. The logic here is sail shape when reefed and I’ve set up so we can both reef & douce from the cockpit. Throughly enjoying the articles. Cheers
Hi Nigel, thanks for the comment. I agree with your thinking on the headsail. It might be worth investigating the staysail option instead of reefing the main headsail, that way you could still go with a furler and just never roller reef. The French multihull racing sailors do this and call it a stockeur. It’s either fully out or fully furled, there’s no in between. We did this on our staysail on Wildling and it worked great. The advantages are that you don’t have to go all the way forward to douse your forward headsail if things get crazy, and you get perfect sail shape on your hanked on staysail when your headsail is too big.
Thanks for the suggestion, I’ll discuss this with the sailmaker. The other considerations for me where weight & windage. This was one furler option I found that might be the right fit for your suggestion. Have slides rather than luff tape really appealed. Look forward to the next update.
Great Post as always, thanks for sharing
Hi Doug. I’m glad to see that you’re getting a new boat. After reading your posts on sailwildling and now puffin, I’ve come to a conclusion- I think you have more fun building your boats than you do actually sailing them (especially motoring in light air)..
Your explanation on reefing was great as far as it went, but you focused on moving ce without addressing clr. Doug, could you play with the daggerboards on Wildling when underway? Reducing the daggerboard area will move Clr. You may be able to postpone reefing by raising the daggerboard by about 20-30 cm.
Remember-“Fast is Fun” http://merlinyachtracing.com/about/
This is all good stuff and appreciated. Helps us first-timers cut a lot of corners when considering boat features.
Doug, curious if you guys are going to put another upsideup system in after your experience with it on Wildling?
Doug, I’m curious if you’re going to put in another UpSideUp system after your experience with it on Wildling?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The UpsideUp system is very good, and they have continued to advance it since we installed the system in Wildling. I decided to not put it in Puffin because the forces are so much less, I feel more confident that we can keep the boat in a safe configuration. I would definitely recommend it for a larger multihull though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Is Puffin the first white 4x? In all the other pics I’ve seen of 4x’s, they have been grey with stripes on the quarter.
The original 4X colors were gray hulls with black mast, black longitudinal beam and bowsprit and black crossbeam. Then they went to white hulls and kept the rest black. I don’t like the black mast and beams so we changed them to white. I believe Puffin is the first all white 4X that they have done.
Hi Doug, many thanks for sharing your considerations, very valuable, I learn from all of them! I have a couple of questions if I may to see if I can ’steal’ some of your ideas. We have an Outremer 45 (2015) – Vassiliki, so your boat but 1-2 knots slower, without the carbon stuff and the transom extensions:) How is the inner forestay supported and in your mind could this be retrofitted – I like the idea of a smaller head sail closer to the center of the boat in windy upwind conditions?
And on the Reef hook, I agree the creaking can really get on your nerves! I think, in addition to the reef line you also need an ‘unlocking’ line when you want to shake the reef? Presumably this line is also led back to the steering wheel position, but if so, how is this done?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Regarding the inner forestay, The longitudinal beam on the 4X is a composite, carbon-reinforced GRP spar required to take the high loads of the staysail. My assumption is that due to the longitudinal beam construction of a 45, you you can’t fit a staysail, but Outremer will need to answer this question. There may be some modifications they can do?
On the reef hook. There are two lines led back to the helm station. One line to pull the leech down and engage the hook, the other line to release it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
True that a staysail is a great help when sailing windward in sustained winds. Most monohulls have it but it is seldom seen on cruising multis, most lacking the attachment point. Well done Outremer for engineering it !
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am new and learning with an aim to buy a catamaran in the future. Something along the lines of a TS42 to TS5 Marsoudon Composites as a max size. Or perhaps a smaller Dazcat or Outremer. Something simple and lightweight. I loved your approach of simplifying things, ie fixed mast etc.
Please suggest anything which will make my life simpler as a solo live aboard life. For example you alluded to a smaller cat may mean simpler sailing rig? Any help much appreciated… Thanks! Paul
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just a small question.
“This is the same track the Outremer 45 uses for its self tacking jib, which we don’t have on our 4X.”
“so because my tradeoff criteria favors easy single-handed sailing over performance, I went with the smaller, self-tacking staysail.”
So in fact you added the track from the 45 ?
Yes, we added the same track the 45 uses for its self tacking jib, and we use it for our self tacking staysail.
Thanks ! and didn’t you hesitate on having the staysail on a stocker and hook (for the hailyard), but non reefing, and maybe making the ORC a tad bigger ?
Yes, I considered the stocker and hook, but the hook is a point of failure and a reliability concern, so I decided on a fixed stay at the mast, and movable at the deck instead. With that arrangement, the best sail solution was having a reef point on the staysail and a smaller ORC. BUT, I do think the stocker is a good option. I would keep a fixed top point on the stay though with the stocker, not a hook. This would not be reefable though.
On Wildling you did not want to have a Parasailor, whats your thoughts about this sail on Puffin?
Parasailors are designed for dead downwind running, and they work great for many catamarans. They don’t do very well on light, performance catamarans that accelerate quickly. What happens is the boat catches the sail during surfs and the sail collapses. The boat then slows and the sail re-inflates. This puts a lot of stress on the sail and makes for an uncomfortable and inefficient passage. I would not use a parasailor on a 5X or 4X, but would certainly consider it on a more traditional, heavy cruising cat.
Hi Doug, we are having a lightweight cat built. I’ve been pondering a parasailor and am interested I your comment. Parasailor say that they can be used on broad reaches as well as dead downwind. Are your 2 comments about 1) wind angles and 2) the issue with lightweight cats from personal experience with one?
Everybody that raves about them seems to sail on a Lagoon or similar (the data may lean that way simply because most boats aren’t lightweight rather than any specific problem with light boats…) and I’ve been looking for someone that has tried one on a lightweight boat!
I was going to buy a parasailor for our 5X but then I talked to another 5X owner who had tried the sail on his boat and it didn’t work well for him. The problem he had was the boat would overtake the parasailor when surfing down waves, which deflated the sail, then the boat would slow down and the sail would crack full again and the boat would lurch forward and the process repeated on the next wave. Very uncomfortable and puts a lot of stress and fatigue on the sail. If you want to fly a symmetric spi, you can consider a smaller, heavy weight fabric that can fly in 30-35 knot trade winds. If you don’t make it too big, you can fly it longer and it won’t deflate as easily.
Thanks Doug for the awesome information. I’ve just got a couple of questions related to your sail plan options. Would you use the same setup on the 5X? and under what sail conditions would you use each of the options indicated? Kind regards. Shane
I have really enjoyed reading your blog. Very useful since we are also looking to build/buy an Outremer.
Your sail handling setup really makes sense. However, I would like to ask if you see a benefit for adding one more electric winch for mainsheet & traveller. Or adding electric line driver (and possibly also electric winch for mainsheet)?
We also want to make our boat extremely easy for solo sailing.
The setup we have on Puffin works well, but I agree, adding an electric winch at the helm would be a benefit. The outboard helm winch is for the genoa sheet and on Puffin it is manual. When unfurling the genoa I can route the sheet over to the inboard electric winch which helps, but trimming the genoa is done manually. The inboard helm winch is electric and handles the main halyard, mainsheet and reefing lines. The starboard roof winch is electric and handles the genoa and the other double ended mainsheet. In the cockpit, the port winch is electric and handles the mainsheet traveler, genoa furler, port daggerboard and port gennaker sheet. The starboard cockpit winch has to be manual because it is located on top of the storage compartment for the propane tank. this winch handles the staysail furler, dinghy lift line, starboard daggerboard and starboard gennaker sheet. We made all the lines long enough to pass across the cockpit to the port electric winch. This setup works very well.
Thank you for explaining! I think this is an excellent setup.
Hi Doug, have you considered adding hooks for reef #2 and #3 since?
Doug, Nice summary of the trade-offs between a fixed, carbon fiber mast & a rotating one. Locating all of the reefing control lines into the cockpit with a fixed mast is beneficial especially if/when reefing solo. With a square top main and full battens putting in the first reef can be quite the challenge due to frictional loads of sail against rig and batten slide cars against mast. A rotating mast would help unload some of these friction loads. How has your experience been with Puffin ? Are there specific slide car systems that you would recommend ? Thanks in advance, your explanations are very thorough ! Rob
We did find reefing on the 5X was easier with the mast rotated, but the mainsail is 69 sq-meters on that boat. The 4X is much smaller, so reefing is very easy and I don’t find the fixed mast presents any problem. We have the Antal mast track system which works well. I give it a spray with sailcote every 6 months and it slides quite easily.